Our Menu
PIZZA
CHOOSE FROM SIZES 7 INCH , 12 INCH , 16 INCH
DOUBLE PEPPERONI
We aren't shy on the pepperoni or cheese. This is what we all ate as kids... don't stop now.
ITALIAN SAUSAGE
Real beautiful Italian sausage with oodles of cheese. Say yes.
VEGGIE
The base is a cheese pizza... we add banana peppers,
BBQ
BBQ sauce base, shredded chicken, red onion, and a houseful of shredded cheese.
DELUXE
Green peppers, banana peppers, mushrooms, olives, sausage, pepperoni
WINGS AND THINGS
CHOOSE FROM:
BUFFALO
HONEY BBQ
SESAME TERIYAKI
MANGO HABANERO
NAKED AND AFRAID
Chicken Wings
Served with choice of sauce. Dipping sauce for an additional charge
Sauce on The Side
Blue Cheese or Ranch
FRIES
OUR ONE SIZE FITS ALL FRIES... ASK FOR THEM CRISP!
You're welcome.
Fries
1 size fits all. Fried potatoes
Loaded Fries
Fries with jalapeno cheese sauce, Monterrey Jack cheese shred, fresh bacon, and sour cream. Comes in a 5 lb. boat
BREAD STICKS
ONE BREADSTICK OR GET A BUNDLE OF 3!
STUFFED BREADSTICKS WITH FENNEL SAUSAGE
STUFFED BREADSTICKS WITH PEPPERONI
SIDE OF JALAPEÑO CHEESE OR RED SAUCE
COLD SAMMIES
RAY'S 1969 HOAGIE
Two kinds of salami, ham, and provolone cheese on our locally famous house-made bread
MARY'S CHICKEN SALAD
We bake our chicken breasts from scratch then add in all of the wonderful things that make a great chicken salad. Red onions, celery, the best of mayonnaise and our secret spices. Okay. Not that secret, any employee would give it up for a small sum of money.
THE TINA TUNA
Only the finest can of tuna. Tuna that we fished out ourselves from the Atlantic- how's that for fresh? Okay. So our supplier delivers this every Monday, so that's the truth of its origin. We add only the best mayonnaise, red onion, celery and of course our secret spices.
CLAIRE'S VEGGIE HEAD
Veggies, veggies and more veggies. Provolone cheese, co-jack cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pickles, green pepper, olives. Add mayonnaise or mustard- the choice is yours. The sandwich will be yours too.
TOM'S TURKEY
Only the finest turkey with provolone on our locally famous from scratch bread. Every turkey deserves some mayonnaise, lettuce and tomatoes... but the choice is yours.
FAT HEAD SALAMI
This isn't complicated. Salami. Cheese. And whatever topping makes you happy. THE END.
WILBUR'S HAM+CHEESE
Close your eyes. Think of the best dinner ham that you can remember. Now, imagine that in a sandwich. That's what this is. Ham and provolone. You pick the toppings. Don't say no to mayo.
DELICIOUS ROB'S ROAST BEEF
Named after a previous Greiner's owner, this roast beef is no walk in the park. Fresh lunch meat sliced daily. Top it in any way that will make you happy.
HOT SAMMIES
OUR HOT SAMMIES. WHICH ARE THE TOP TWO, YOU ASK?... THE HOT TODDY AND THE STEAK AND CHEESE. BUT YES, THEY ARE ALL WONDERFUL!
THE HOT TODDY
Momma was in Hungary when she made this one. Meat, meat, and more meat. Turkey, pepperoni, ham, capicola, cheddar cheese, and jalapeno cheese toasted on house-made bread, not for the weak of heart. We say one word after this sammie is ordered- "Congratulations."
OWEN'S PHILLY CHEESE STEAK
Our Famous Philly cheese steak, the same since 1969. Voted #1 cheesesteak
TRUMAN'S MUSHROOM STEAK
Our steak with homemade mushroom gravy
LUCY'S PIZZA STEAK
Our steak and cheese with hot red sauce on our fresh bread
BBQ CHICKEN
Shredded chicken breast covered in BBQ sauce and all warmed up and toasted to greatness
MEATHEAD MEATBALL
Meatballs and cheese, how can you go wrong
NOT YOUR HOT POCKET STROMBOLI
Fresh ham and sausage together with pizza sauce on house bread
LUKE'S COUNTRY SAUSAGE
Country sausage chopped up on house-made bread. Dressed however you want it
GYRO
Lamb and beef on hot pita... unless of course you request it on our locally famous bread.
BLT
What can you say? It's a BLT made for the hungry
MOTHER CLUCKER CHICKEN
Baked shredded chicken breast and provolone cheese melted on top of freshly baked bread
MADELINE'S ITALIAN BEEF
Sliced roast beef soaked in a au jus with provolone cheese toasted to perfection on our house-made bread. If your heart desires, add the classic giardinera to top.
MRS. CHANDLER'S PB+J
Peanut butter and grape jelly grilled and melted together in the perfect way all toasted on our house made bread. Sure, it's a little messy, but napkins are free.
MAC GENIE MAC+CHEESE
FROM THE FOOD TRUCK OFF THE STREETS OF INDY, THE LOCALLY FAMOUS MAC+CHEESE. WE CONVERT MAC+CHEESE HATERS TO LOVERS. WE PROMISE.
THE OG
Locally famous mac + cheese from the Mac Genie truck
BUFFALO GENIE
Our locally famous mac with mild buffalo sauce and chicken
JALAPEÑO GENIE
That same locally famous mac with a bit of heat thrown in with some jalapeños
NAKED AND AFRAID
Our same famous mac with nothing extra on top. And it's still beautiful.